Missing the forest for the data? Conflicting valuations of the forest and cultivable lands

Cheyns Emmanuelle, Silva-Castañeda Laura, Aubert Pierre-Marie. 2019. Missing the forest for the data? Conflicting valuations of the forest and cultivable lands. Land Use Policy, 10 p.

Journal article ; Article de recherche ; Article de revue à facteur d'impact
[img] Version Online first - Anglais
Access restricted to CIRAD agents
Use under authorization by the author or CIRAD.
article in press.pdf

Télécharger (2MB) | Request a copy


Liste HCERES des revues (en SHS) : oui

Thème(s) HCERES des revues (en SHS) : Géographie-Aménagement-Urbanisme-Architecture

Abstract : In reaction to Greenpeace campaigns denouncing the impact of oil palm plantations in Southeast Asia, Golden Agri-Resources (GAR) – a major actor in the palm oil sector – adopted a zero-deforestation policy. The implementation of this policy raised a simple, albeit tricky, question: what is a forest? In response, Greenpeace, GAR and a consultancy firm developed a methodology for forest classification called the High Carbon Stock (HCS) Approach. Employing a vegetation classification based primarily on a threshold of carbon sequestration, the method identifies which forested zones to protect from conversion to agriculture. While currently gaining resonance in the realm of sustainability standards, its implementation in Indonesia and Liberia encountered resistance and criticism by rural dwellers and social NGOs. How did HCS advocates integrate local peoples' concerns, interests and claims to compose commonality? By analysing the HCS methodology's content, implementation and progressive adaptation, this article shows how HCS advocates favoured a specific mode of composition: one that fits a liberal grammar and that has specific implications on the valuation of forest and cultivable lands. The HCS approach is thus more than a data collection tool; it encapsulates and reinforces a particular vision of the environment and how people should relate to it.

Mots-clés Agrovoc : Forêt, Elaeis guineensis, Déboisement, séquestration du carbone, protection de la forêt

Mots-clés géographiques Agrovoc : Asie du Sud-Est, Indonésie, Libéria

Mots-clés libres : Environmental valuation, Pragmatic sociology, Forest conservation, Oil palm, High carbon stock

Classification Agris : K01 - Forestry - General aspects
K70 - Forest injuries and protection
P01 - Nature conservation and land resources

Champ stratégique Cirad : CTS 5 (2019-) - Territoires

Auteurs et affiliations

  • Cheyns Emmanuelle, CIRAD-ES-UMR MOISA (FRA) - auteur correspondant
  • Silva-Castañeda Laura, UCL (BEL)
  • Aubert Pierre-Marie, IDDRI (FRA)

Source : Cirad-Agritrop (

View Item (staff only) View Item (staff only)

[ Page générée et mise en cache le 2021-04-13 ]